Videos by According2HipHop
When Jay-Z announced The Black Album in 2003, it was framed as his final bow—his “retirement” album. Instead, it became a defining moment, a masterclass in artistry, charisma, and cultural dominance. Packed with elite production and some of Jay’s sharpest writing, the project remains one of the most important albums of the 2000s.
Here’s a ranking of every track on The Black Album, from least to greatest—though on a project this strong, “least” is still elite.
13. “Justify My Thug”
Produced by DJ Quik, the song has a cool West Coast feel, but compared to the album’s emotional depth and sonic highs, it lands at the bottom. Jay’s verses are solid, but it’s the only moment that feels slightly disconnected from the album’s narrative weight.
12. “Moment of Clarity”
With Eminem behind the boards, this should’ve been an automatic top-tier record. Jay’s reflections on fame, his father, and commercial expectations are insightful, but the beat’s simplicity keeps it from soaring. Still, its transparency is noteworthy.
11. “My 1st Song”
The “retirement” outro is cinematic and motivational, inspired by Biggie’s interviews. Jay blends hunger with reflection, ending the album with a message: start every day like it’s your first. A strong closer, but not in the absolute top tier.
10. “Change Clothes”
The Pharrell-assisted single was a radio smash—smooth, fashionable, and hook-heavy. A great song, but lighter in tone than the album’s more powerful records, which pushes it toward the middle of the pack.
9. “Threat”
9th Wonder’s chopped R. Kelly sample is clever, and Jay’s threats are delivered with tongue-in-cheek energy. Bar for Bar some of the best rhyming you will hear on this classic album. Jay Z is in a ZONE on this song.
8. “December 4th”
The autobiographical storytelling—complete with Gloria Carter’s narration—makes this one of Jay’s most personal songs ever. It’s vivid, reflective, and full of character. A great scene-setter for the album’s introspective framework.
7. “Dirt Off Your Shoulder”
Timbaland and Jay-Z in championship form. The beat is instantly iconic, and Jay floats across it with effortless swagger. It doubled as cultural shorthand for brushing off criticism—cementing its significance beyond music.
6. “Allure”
One of the most debated songs to rank. Pharrell’s sultry, hypnotic production paired with Jay’s confessions about the grip of street life has made this a fan favorite. Beautifully written, yet overshadowed by the album’s true heavy hitters.
5. “Encore”
A flawless stadium anthem. Kanye West gives Jay a heroic victory-lap instrumental, and Jay delivers a curtain-call performance worthy of the moment. In the album’s “farewell” context, this is a masterpiece.
4. “Lucifer”
Kanye’s production is volcanic, one of the most explosive beats on the album. Jay brings sharp lyricism and biblical themes, making this both menacing and spiritual. It remains a fan favorite for a reason.
3. “99 Problems”
Rick Rubin’s hard-rock production transforms Jay into a snarling storyteller. It’s aggressive, political, rebellious, and catchy—an anthem that transcended genres. One of the greatest singles in his catalog.
2. “What More Can I Say”
The opener feels like a declaration of dominance. Movie-sample intro, triumphant horns, and Jay’s verbal fireworks make this the perfect tone-setter. It’s Jay at his most boastful and self-aware.
1. “PSA (Interlude)”
Two minutes. That’s all it took for Jay-Z to create one of the most iconic songs of his career. Just Blaze’s thunderous beat drop is legendary, and Jay delivers pure lyrical venom. This isn’t just an interlude—it’s a moment in Hip-Hop history.
